the Best Brownies Ever

Brownies. Classic. Simple. Yet not so simple.  All brownies were NOT created equal!  In fact, the variance between brownies, in quality and taste, can be vast, yet they all go by the same name of Brownie!  I have realized in the past few years that I have a complex relationship with Brownies.  They are, on one hand, a dessert that I can pass up- if they are tough, or chewy from a box (you know, just add water, plain ole box brownies).  However, when brownies are dense and rich and homemade and fudgy and gooey, I don’t know if there is a dessert I love more.  How could it be?  I try not to be a “brownie snob” but I have been known to ask a brownie-bringer to,  “tell me more about them”, which sounds a little ridiculous as I type out the words!  But my underlying question really is, “are they worth the calories?” Because we know that: 1. all brownies are not created equal and that: 2. they are all full of fat and calories.
I have a great, classic, go-to brownie recipe that I have made for years that I got from my mom.  Cocoa is the source of chocolate in it.  It’s yummy and can be whipped up in a jiffy.  However,  a couple of years ago, my friend Lane emailed me this recipe with the subject line  “the just right brownie”.  We are always searching for the “just right” recipes. And she found it with this one.  (You need to check out her beautiful, inspiring blog-Apron Days)
Well, just right it is!  It is made with 4 cups of chocolate chips; 2 cups melted into loads of melted butter and sugar and 2 cups stirred into the batter with the dry ingredients to evenly distribute.  They are fudgy, oh my goodness, rich and substantial.  I have been making them for the past couple of years as my new go-to brownie and playing around with mix-ins, toppings, etc.

And I must speak to brownie batter since it is one of Dave’s favorite things on the planet!  Because it is full of raw eggs, Dave gets dibs on it (I don’t want to give it to my kids).  So he doesn’t even have to play rock/scissors/paper to determine the bowl/beater/spoon licker.  Last year for his birthday he asked for brownie batter for his cake.  Really? Wierd.  So I made a smaller pan of brownies and the rest of the batter was served in a bowl. He loves the gritty sugar texture and the rich chocolate.  When he sees me reaching for the rubber spatula (his enemy) to scrape the bowl he says, “Really? Do you have to scrape it with the rubber spatula?”  It is much too thorough and leaves far too little for him.

  • I decided this was the week to post about these Just Right Brownies for 2 reasons:  1.  My sister’s birthday is this week and she loves a good brownie.  She loves gooey, rich chocolate desserts.  For her birthday she typically prefers brownies with hot fudge and ice cream over a birthday cake.  She says that she sees cake as simply the vehicle to carry icing- since the icing is the part she loves.  So, because her birthday is in December and peppermint ice cream is available (and we love it), we often times have brownies with peppermint ice cream and hot fudge for her “birthday cake”.  I got to make it last year for her 40th birthday and used this recipe. The recipe is birthday worthy.  So happy birthday Jennifer!
  • The other reason I wanted to post it is because one of my favorite varieties of this is Peppermint Brownies, which are so Christmasy!  I replace the 2 tsp.vanilla with 1 tsp. peppermint extract.  Then a few minutes before the brownies are done, I reach in and sprinkle crushed peppermint on the top of the brownies (see Peppermint Bark post for crushing instructions).  They are so pretty and YUMMY!
  • You can also make the classic brownies and then have toppings so that everyone can make it their way.  Like this week when my girls’ group came over and we had brownies with vanilla ice cream, crushed peppermint and toasted sliced almonds as toppings with our brownies.


  • Another variety that is a consistent hit is Symphony brownies.  Have you ever made them?  I don’t know who thought them up, but Paula Deen’s cookbook was the first place I saw the idea.  They are a very special brownie- and leave people wondering about  the lovely filling.  You take Hershey’s Symphony Bars-the big ones (Symphony bars are milk chocolate bars with bits of toffee and almonds) and spread ½ of the brownie batter in the pan and then cover with 3 large symphony bars and then top with dollops of the remaining ½ of batter and gently spread together.  Bake normally and you have a chocolate almond toffee filling sandwiched between two amazing brownie layers.  (If you want to add another touch, you can throw some sliced almonds on top when there are a few minutes of bake time remaining)!
  • A little brownie tip- Cut brownies with a plastic knife…it’s amazing!  Something about the plastic doesn’t stick to the brownie like a metal knife does.  And you get beautifully-cut, gooey brownies.  Try it!
Brownies.  So much to say about them!  I love that brownies are just about perfect with ice cream and hot fudge and yet they pack great for a road trip, and are versatile when adding toppings and layers.  Happy baking!
 2/3 cup butter (11 Tbsp)
1 1⁄4 cup sugar
1⁄4 cup water (or you can substitute brewed coffee for a little mocha kick)
4 cups (24oz) semi-sweet chocolate chips, divided
4 eggs
2 tsp vanilla
1 1⁄2 cups flour
1⁄2 tsp baking soda
1⁄2 tsp salt
Preheat oven to 325 degrees. Grease 13×9-inch baking pan
In heavy sauce pan, bring butter, sugar, water to boil, stirring until butter is melted and sugar dissolved
(or do this in the microwave).
Remove from heat and stir in 2 cups of the chocolate chips until all are melted. Cool a bit, then add vanilla.
In large mixing bowl, whisk eggs, then gradually add the chocolate mix, stirring with spoon until entirely mixed.  In another bowl, mix flour, baking soda and salt, followed by the rest of the chocolate chips, until combined. Finally, stir the dry into the wet, mixing well.  Spread into the pan and bake for 33-35 minutes until cooked through.  Do not over-bake! 


5 thoughts on “the Best Brownies Ever

  1. Jennifer says:

    I made Lane's brownies last night! I used the 2 cups of choc. chips melted in, but for the 2 cups to stir in at the end I used a bag of chopped up Andes mints. Yummy!!! Now I just need that peppermint ice cream to go with them…


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s